Fantasy Cone – is it icecream or ice dessert?
New products hit the supermarket shelves on a daily basis. With nearly 20,000 people in the Additive Free Kids community, we have eyes out everywhere. In the private community group we will often talk about new products and what we think of them. Would we buy them? Would we avoid them? Why? One of our gorgeous community members sent me a ripper this week.
This new product was a Coles product – Fantasy cones (Unicorn cones) – Vanilla and Raspberry . There is another similar product called Mermaid Cones – Vanilla and bubblegum. The concern was that parents are being taken advantage of. I would have to agree! I thought I would share my thoughts with you.
These products have on the front of pack label:
“No Artificial Colours or Flavours”
Ignore the front of pack claims
I know I say this all the time. IGNORE the front of pack claims. Always, always, always flip it over. Check out the ingredients.
I know the packaging looks beautiful mums. Hundreds of thousands of dollars (if not more!) would have been spent on making that packaging look amazing.
It is designed to get your attention. It is designed to capture the hearts of every little girl that loves unicorns and mermaids. I know that your girls will LOVE them. I know they look cute. However, do you LOVE the ingredients?
You are being duped. I will explain the reasons why…
I was only able to find the ingredients for the Vanilla & Raspberry Fantasy Cone online.
Ingredient review
Vanilla flavoured ice dessert:
– Reconstituted skimmed milk
– Sugar
– Coconut oil
– Glucose syrup
– Whey powder
– Skim milk powder
– Emulsifiers (mono and diglycerides of fatty acids)
– Stabiliser (Locust bean gum, guar gum
– Natural flavour
– Plant concentrate (Spirulina)
– Natural colour (curcumin)
Raspberry flavoured ice dessert:
– Reconstituted skimmed milk
– Sugar
– Raspberry juice from concentrate
– Coconut oil
– Glucose syrup
– Whey powder
– Skim milk powder
– Emulsifiers (mono and diglycerides of fatty acids)
– Acidity regulators (citric acid)
– Natural flavour
– Stabiliser (Locust bean gum, guar gum)
Wafer cone: – Wheat flour
– Sugar
– Cocoa powder
– Coconut oil
– Emulsifier (soy lecithins)
– Natural colour (153)
– Salt
– Anticaking agent (magnesium carbonate)
Cocoa coating:
– Coconut oil
– Sugar
– Fat reduced cocoa powder
Can anyone see what is happening here?
I was on the money! Instead of using cream, milk and other milk products have been used. They are bulked up with gums, flavour and emulsifiers to resemble the real thing.
Why?
Because they think you won’t notice.
Because cream is expensive in comparison.
Mums are pushed for time in the supermarket.
Mums will be distracted with the clever marketing of uni-cones or fantasy-cones.
Kids will pester.
They think that you will pay more for this product because it has natural colours and flavours. What is the point of using natural colours if you still have all these other additives in the product?
Don’t be fooled!
What ingredients should you find in an icecream?
Cream (first and most important ingredient!),
milk,
egg yolks,
sugar and
vanilla
What ingredients should you find in an ice dessert?
Frozen fruit puree or
fresh fruit juices frozen.
No concentrates, no extracts.
We need to stick to the basics. Don’t let the marketing machines fool you that this product is any better than any of the other products on the supermarket shelves.
I wouldn’t touch this.
You can’t expect to buy this product and not have repercussions. Those repercussions might not be in the short term, but they will be in the long term.
Lets take a look at why I say that.
Emulsifiers
All those emulsifiers are destroying your kids’ gut microbiome. Study after study is being realised highlighting what the emulsifiers, lecithins, mono and diglycerides of fatty acids are doing to us.
All disease starts in the gut.
Perhaps one ice dessert won’t do it. How many emulsifiers are your kids ingesting every day, every week, every year?
Do you know?
Natural colours aren’t always better
Lets look at the natural colour (153) that was used in this cone. A quick look in the Chemical Maze app will how you that 153 is Carbon blacks or vegetable carbons.
This may be genetically modified.
This colour is usually derived from burnt vegetable matter. It is mildly toxic by ingestion.
Take note of this: it is prohibited in foods for infants.
This should be a warning light to all!
Vegetable carbon can contain carcinogenic substances. This can also result in eczema itching, hives, rashes. Not particularly good for your child’s long term health.
But…..it says Natural Flavours
I know the pack says no artificial flavours. I know the ingredients list NATURAL flavours.
These natural flavours, this one ingredient could have another 50 ingredients behind it. You have no idea what they are. The manufacturers do not need to disclose them to you!
Call Coles, and ask them what is in their natural flavours. The standard response will most likely be:
“I am sorry, we are unable to divulge that information. That information is intellectual property.”
Natural wholefoods do NOT need intellectual property protection! Please avoid all flavours – whether they are Natural or Artificial.
I could keep going on about this ingredient list….but, the message is very simple and clear.
When you look at the ingredients – are you getting what you pay for?
Is the manufacturer doing the right thing by you and your family? Or are they interested in profits firs?
Let me know if this review was helpful.
If you would like to chat and be supported by thousands of other Mums and Dads on the additive free journey, come and join the Additive Free Kids email list. Receive free support directly to your inbox.
Thankyou so much for your wonderful work reviewing these products. It is so important that we know what we are giving our kids to eat. As you explained all these stabilisers and emulsifiers are really just bulking up an inferior base ingredient to avoid the cost of using a superior product like real cream and eggs. Cost is the driving force in the manufacturing of these products. Thanks again for doing the research on what some of these mystery ingredients really are.
Hi Natalie
You are welcome. We all have a right to know what is in our food.
Thank you for your comment
Frankie
Thankyou so much. These reviews are fantastic. I love how you put is so simply. They are trying to baffle us with BS and we will not take it anymore.
Hi Tracey
Thank you for your comment. We all need to vote with our dollar. If we don’t buy they won’t make them.
Frankie
My kids would love these looking at them! But thanks to your review I will be steering clear!
You are welcome 🙂
Some feedback on your comments….
This product is an Ice Dessert – it doesn’t pretend to be Ice Cream and it is made to a commonly accepted standard in Australia (eg same as Blue Ribbon). If you reviewed some of the very large brands in Australia, you would find that many are not legally Ice Cream (and avoid the use of these words on pack)
In terms of E153 or Vegetable carbon, it is known as vegetable black, or carbo medicinalis vegetabilis. It is an insoluble black food colouring used in confectionery products, icing, baked goods and ice cream. Australian, European and Canadian authorities approve its use as a colour additive. It is NON GMO
Vegetable carbon is produced through steam activation (charring) of Coconut fibres. The Manufacturer grounds the activated vegetable source into very small particles before adding glucose or glycerin for ease of use in food. it is currently very popular in health foods as well and is also used for its ability to absorb toxins. It has no known side effects apart from potential constipation (if consumed in excessive quantity- due to its absorbancy attributes)or slight colouration of bowel movements (again if consumed in excessive amounts)
http://www.food-info.net/uk/e/e153.htm
The % used in this Wafer Cone and the similar Mermaid Cone is 0.8%, and as a % of the total Ice Dessert is 0.13%. This will have none of the above mentioned potential effects
I hope this allows your readers to make a balanced decision on a fun product which Children can enjoy in moderation as with all treats
Thank you for your comments. It is great to know that E153 is NON GMO. I understand your comments. The fact still remains that this ingredient is prohibited for infants. Unfortunately, whilst you may have tackled one of the ingredients in this product there are plenty other ingredients in this product that we would recommend avoiding for children and families that are sensitive and health conscious – emulsifiers and flavours as examples. Do you have further information on these? It would be great if you could also declare your interest here – do you assist Coles with the marketing and development of this product?