I have been asked by many in the AFK Community if I have watched the new The Game Changers documentary that focuses on plant based proteins. If you aren’t aware, it is a new film on Netflix. It was produced by James Cameron, Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jackie Chan.
The movie looks at the explosive rise of plant based eating in professional sports. It follows the story of James Wilks – an elite Special Forces trainer and winner of The Ultimate Fighter as he embarks on a quest for the truth about meat, protein and strength.
This film has caused quite the stir….I already held suspicions before even watching it…wondering whether it was a covert marketing ploy to convince the public to switch to new plant based proteins.
I am seeing a MASSIVE rise of plant based ‘proteins’ hit supermarket shelves. The plant based protein market is estimated to reach a value of USD $40.6 billion by 2025 (1). This is a BIG $ industry.
Potential financial rewards behind this documentary and plant based proteins
There are some big investors behind these new plant protein products including:
Impossible food investors:
Serena Williams
Jay-Z
Katy Perry
Jaden Smith
Trevor Noah
Zedd
Bill Gates
Beyond Meat
Bill Gates
Leonardo Di Caprio
Don Thompson (former McDonald’s CEO)
Chris Paul (producer Gamer Changers)
I can tell you that within 30 minutes of watching this documentary… I felt like I was being marketed to….covertly.
My first question was….are the producers benefiting financially from promoting a plant based protein diet?
A quick google search showed me that the executive producer: James Cameron (award winning film maker (Titanic, Avatar), and his wife have invested US$140million in plant based proteins, including a company (Verdiant Foods) that produces pea protein (a key ingredient in Beyond Meat) with the goal of becoming the “largest pea protein fractionation facility in North America”.
I believe we always need to understand where is the funding coming from and who is influencing these documentaries or articles.
This had now set the scene for me…
It’s not all or nothing?
The next thing that came to mind as I am watching is how it was a very all or nothing approach.
You are either a vegan or a meat eater….with little conversation or acknowledgement that meat eaters can also eat a large quantity of vegetables / plant based proteins too.
It doesn’t have to be an all or nothing approach…
Ironic link to sporting heroes?
I thought it a little ironic that the documentary discusses how people were sold the story that smoking was good for you by sporting heroes. “The tobacco industry turned to famous athletes, the ultimate symbols of fitness and health”.
For years the tobacco industry said their products didn’t cause cancer. Until the evidence began to show that it did.
I can’t help but think …this is exactly what this documentary is doing!!
A new industry is being created, they are trying to convert the masses, by saying that these famous athletes (the ultimate symbols of fitness and health) are eating it….you should do it too….
I would argue, that as a population, we won’t know the impact that the ultra processed isolated proteins will have on human health for the next 20-30 years. By then, the industry will be fully established and scullions of dollars made.
Listen to your body…
I understand the perspective that animal production adds significantly to global warming.
I understand that people care about the planet and our global health.
I believe everyone has a right to choose which ever diet suits them best.
We are all different.
Some work better with meat, others with vegetables.
You need to listen to your body and what works best for you.
I believe that you can still love animals, care about the environment, honour your own bodies and consume the food that you need.
Do your research…
I am seeing these ‘PROTEINS” appear in any and every product, from drinks, dairy alternatives, meat alternatives, sports nutrition products, even in kids muesli bars. These plant based proteins are usually derived from plant sources such as soy, wheat and pea. The range is increasing at rapid rates.
I want to impress upon you, … research your food sources…so that you can make an informed decision for your family.
I understand that is very compelling watching these documentaries and knowing all these celebrities and sporting heroes are supporting the plant based protein movement.
People are being sold on the plant based protein diet as it being a cleaner alternative, healthy, ethically and naturally sourced and less processed.
What I would like you to consider is…..
What processing has been undertaken to obtain these isolated proteins?
Do these occur naturally?
What we need to understand is that the original sources of these proteins are great for us, they are a great quality protein and complete. They come together in a package of nutrients.
To create soy protein or soy protein isolates they are chemically engineered to “isolate’ their protein. All the other nutrients are stripped out.
“Soy protein isolates have been known and produced for industrial purposes, mainly as adhesives for the paper coating industry, well before World War II. ISP’s for food use, however, have been developed only in the early fifties” (2).
You need to ask the question what are the typical ways in which these proteins are extracted?
Often they are extracted using aluminium or hexane. Hexane is a neurotoxic petrochemical solvent that is listed as a hazardous air pollutant with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (3)
A research article in the Journal of Experimental and Clinical Toxicology ISSN: 2641-7669 (here) states low or acute exposures to hexane might cause “several human health implications such as polyneuropathy, muscular weakness, headache, dizziness, giddiness, slight nausea. It has been reported by Q’Quinn et al (1997) that hexane may cause some degeneration of the digestive system of animals. Hexane residue has been found toxic to humans and animals at relatively low concentrations as mentioned by Sparks et al (2006).“
The proteins will still contain some of this residue. It is a chemically modified and highly processed product.
If you are vegan I would recommend asking the question, how has the protein been isolated? Ideally, you should be looking for natural whole protein sources like beans, lentils, nuts and seeds.
Are isolated proteins a game changer….not in my book…
What did you think of the documentary?
What are you thoughts on isolated proteins?
Comment below.
(2) http://www.fao.org/3/t0532e/t0532e07.htm
(3) https://www.cornucopia.org/2009/05/soy-report-and-scorecard/
If you would like to be kept up to date with the latest news, product reviews and giveaways come and join us in the Additive Free Kids Community.
Frankie Bell is the Managing Director of Additive Free Kids, a food coach, mentor and is one of Australia’s leading activists against additives in foods.
Frankie is a mum to 5 boys and has personal experience working through the damaging effects of additives to resolve the multiple health issues and behavioural problems in her own children. It became Frankie’s purpose to help other families achieve the same improvements for their families.
These changes can be overwhelming, especially for time poor parents, Frankie has done all the hard work for families to ensure they have access to additive free food, anytime, anywhere. Additive Free Kids specialises in assisting families to live healthy lives free from additives. See how you can work together with Frankie here.
I couldnt agree with you more. I havent seen the documentry but a year or so ago, was keen to try allthese vegan options that were popping up on the shelves. I grabbed some of the beyond meat, it smells absolutely horrible, I had to hold my nose in order to eat it. Granted it tasted pretty much like meat, but the ingredients list was like a novel. I found the same thing across the majority of the preprepared vegan options. I would absolutely agree that we should reduce the amount of meat we eat, and even try to get organic etc, but I think people just really need to check the ingredients of the food they choose. Thats why i love your page so much!!!
Thanks Nyssa for taking the time to comment. I just feel that they are being taken advantage of….if they have all the information then they can make an educated decision x
I am vegetarian/ vegan. However, I don’t agree with vegans, that eat these products. They are too artificial for me and have too many ingredients.
I’m cooking from scratch and I’m feeling so much better.
My new housemate has all the products in the freezer and I just can shake my head and try to educate her.
Thanks for the great article.
Glad to hear that you are feeling better. We are all different and need to listen to our bodies.
You are welcome!
Yep, check the ingredients
Exactly!
I agree with what you are saying about the fake meats being heavily processed and not necessarily healthy but I’ve watched the documentary twice and loved it. I didn’t feel like I was being covertly convinced to eat the fake meat alternatives.
That being said my approach to eating is predominantly whole foods based so when I think of a vegan diet I think of whole foods with protein coming from legumes, nuts, seeds and veggies. I think most sensible vegan athletes would be eating this sort of thing too. The ones I know are very much into nutrition, whole foods and superfoods.
In fact a large part of the doco was talking about how large quantities of protein for athletes isn’t as important as they once thought with the large plates of meats off the menu and the healthy carbs from veggies back in.
I also remember the section where they talked about it not having to be an all or nothing thing and you can start with meatless Monday’s or just reducing your intake of animal products and still experience great improvements in your overall health.
I aspire to live a more vegan diet for the planet, for my health and because I feel great when I eat an optimum whole foods diet. I’m not strict with it and still eat butter, occasional cheese and meat maybe once per week.
The fake meat industry is definitely fast growing but it’s growing to meet the demand of people who probably used to happily chow down on a Mac Donald’s prior to turning vegan and were looking for something to fill the gap and feed their habits and cravings.
Better nutritional education is needed all round to help people learn more about their food and what they are putting into their bodies.
I believe documentaries like Game Changers serve as a great way to inspire people to learn more about nutrition and their health and see the positive benefits of living a more plant based diet.
And that I believe is a great thing 😀
Thanks for your comment Lucy..I couldn’t agree more…the documentary is definitely inspiring more people to look into nutrition.
There are so many aspects to this documentary though!
This is a really great podcast that analyses the Game Changers documentary in a very methodical and scientific way…I encourage everyone to listen to it and then decide for yourself what works best for you…when you have all the information presented:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dq4Apc2Xk7Q
Chris Kresser, M.S., L.Ac is a globally recognized leader in the fields of ancestral health, Paleo nutrition, and functional and integrative medicine.
The podcast is long….nearly 3 hours worth….you might want to read a snapshot instead here, with lots of scientific data to back up his views.
https://chriskresser.com/debunking-the-game-changers-joe-rogan/?utm_source=rogandebate&utm_medium=shortlink&utm_term=rogandebate&utm_content=&utm_campaign=gamechangers
I think we all agree that there are problems with our current farming practices….and these need to change asap.
Frankie
x
Hey Frankie,
This video has just been released and is the better Youtube video to watch in terms of showing a more balanced argument of the “Debunking” of gamechangers, as this time James Wilkes is there with Chris Kresser and Joe Rogan and is allowed to offer his opinion of why he believes Chris Kresser’s evidence is factually wrong in many occasion when he was allowed to speak without question.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0zgNY_kqlI
There are good points from both sides in this video and should be considered before believing a full “debunking”
But fundamentally I think we agree xx
Hey Lucy
I look forward to listening to this….will take a while!!
Frankie